Dear authors,

Thank you for your thorough revision in light of the reviewer's comments. A much stronger connecting thread now runs through your manuscript, which is also easier to read in its revised version.

My only suggestion at this stage is that you split the abstract, starting a second paragraph at "In this paper..." Please also consider acknowledging your reviewers, all three of whom have given you well articulated and constructive comments.

Kind regards,
Lucia Perez Diaz

Dear Cristina, Clare and Thomas,

We are pleased to let you know that your manuscript 'How can geologic decision making under uncertainty be improved?' is accepted for publication in Solid Earth, pending a couple of minor technical corrections as specified by the Topical Editor Lucia Perez Diaz:
-/ to split the abstract, starting a second paragraph at "In this paper..." , and
-/ to please consider acknowledging the three reviewers.

Thank you for submitting your work to Solid Earth!
Susanne